Oreck XL Air Purifiers – Not as Good as Advertised
I’m sure many of you have seen them, the Oreck XL air purifier that is frequently advertised on TV.
The Oreck XL air purifiers are promoted as a powerful air purifier that can clean the air in your room of allergens and odors. Oreck also claims that the Oreck XL air purifier does not need any filter replacement or maintenance.
Untrue Claims About the Oreck XL
First of all, the claim that you do not need to replace any filters is just flat out not true. The Oreck XL does indeed have 4 carbon filters that need to be replaced on a regular basis. These carbon filters are what the Oreck XL uses to remove odors from the air. These little carbon filters are also expensive, often being sold for $39.95 for a 4 pack.
Also, the Oreck XL claims that it can filter bacteria and mold, and also makes a claim that it will kill harmful bacteria. This is probably true to some extent, but the Oreck XL will not capture and remove nearly as much harmful bacteria and mold from the air as a good HEPA filter.
Also, the Oreck XL needs to generate ozone to kill bacteria. The amount of ozone that is generated is so small that it really won’t make a large impact on bacteria in the air if there is any. The amounts of ozone that would be required to efficiently kill all bacteria in the air would also be harmful to humans. So basically, the claim of killing bacteria is true only to a certain small degree.
Wonky Filtering Mechanisms
The Oreck XL air purifier uses a metal grid filter to capture particles from the air. The metal grid is electronically charged, that is how it gets particles to stick to it. Sure, this will capture some particles out of the air, but as soon as particles start to build up on the filter (after only a few days in most cases) the majority of the air that is being sucked through the machine is really not being cleaned at all, since the grid has started to collect more particles than can stick to it overall.
If you clean the metal grid frequently, you will probably get some results from the Oreck XL, but once again, you will not get nearly the same air cleaning results as you would from a good air purifier that uses a HEPA filter.
The worst thing about all this is the on the advertisements the Oreck XL claims to be better than a HEPA filter, and also claims that HEPA filters are much more costly to maintain. This really isn’t the case. A HEPA filter will capture and remove organisms from the air that are 0.3 microns in size, and a HEPA filter will continue to filter and clean the air even after it starts to get dirty. When the metal grid filter in an Oreck XL begins to get dirty (after a few days) it’s effectiveness drops considerably until it is cleaned.
Conclusions
Many users of the Oreck XL may find that it does remove allergens and particles from the air. They may see that this unit does actually work to some extent, and therefore not really think that there are better options available. The truth is that pretty much any air purifier that uses and HEPA filter will pull many more times air through it and will remove many more times the particles and harmful substances from the air than an Oreck XL will.
If these Oreck XL owners had actually been using and air purifier with a HEPA filter before trying the Oreck XL air purifier they would indeed find that the Oreck XL filtration methods cannot hold a candle to a true HEPA filter.
Don’t buy into the hype on TV about the Oreck XL. Spend your money ($350 in most cases) on an air purifier that uses a true HEPA filter and do a proper job of cleaning the air inside your home. You will not regret it.
